Photo: Pixabay / Pexels
Kazakhstan’s Supreme Audit Chamber has uncovered financial violations worth 51 billion tenge in the science sector. Another 47 billion tenge involved inefficient planning and use of funds. The audit examined how funding was allocated, the results of research projects and spending controls (informburo.kz).
What happened
From 2022 to 2025, science spending rose from 122 billion to 262 billion tenge. Yet the audit found shortcomings in how money was allocated and project results were assessed.
Through the Science Fund, the government finances the commercialisation of research, turning it into products for sale. Of 141 completed projects, 38 achieved steady sales. The remaining 103 projects, worth 22 billion tenge, missed their production and sales targets.
The reported commercialisation rate was 44%. However, a comparable calculation for the reporting year put it at 16%. The gap concerns the assessment of how many research developments made it to market.
What this means for science funding
The audit identified risks of conflicts of interest in funding decisions. Of the 225 members of national scientific councils, 84 also belonged to research teams working on 127 projects worth 52 billion tenge. Among them, 27 led research projects.
Another 62 billion tenge went to 79 projects under targeted programme funding without the required spending breakdowns. This mechanism allocates money to research programmes with defined goals. Those carrying out the projects could receive 96–98% of the project’s value before the final assessment of results.
Here’s an important detail: almost the entire sum could be paid out before the final result was confirmed. Auditors pointed to weaknesses in controls over budget spending.
Which findings will be referred for review
Following the audit, materials on 36 cases were referred for review to determine whether administrative penalties were warranted. A decision was made to refer materials on three instances to law enforcement agencies. The relevant authorities will have to determine whether there is evidence of criminal offences and who bears responsibility.
Oversight of public money also features in the audit of government support for businesses. A separate article covers another research funding tool: a National Bank grant to study wealth distribution.
The next step following the science audit is a review of the referred materials and a legal assessment of the findings.